BWCA Portage Boots - the TR1 Merge is back - 2.0 Boundary Waters Gear Forum
Chat Rooms (0 Chatting)  |  Search  |   Login/Join
* BWCA is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum
   Gear Forum
      Portage Boots - the TR1 Merge is back - 2.0     
 Forum Sponsor

Author

Text

portagedog09
distinguished member (174)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/14/2024 03:34PM  
Well, it will be in August that is. I inquired at the Astral Designs booth at Canoecopia and Baylor was kind enough to let me know that, yes, the TR1 Merge is back in 2.0 trim. Unfortunately, it is not available until August he said. He pulled out a demo pair they had in a box - low and behold - in my size! He let me try them on and they were just as light and comfortable as version 1.0. He even let me take some pics. Baylor said they incorporated some updates based on customer input and field trials. Here are some side-by-side pics compared with my 1.0's. From what I can tell, the metal eyelets are gone, the collar seems a bit more cushioned, the heel pull is vertical and there is double stitching on the toe rand vs. single. The footbed and aggressive sole tread are carry-overs. If they have improved the durability, this should be a win. My 1.0's are still serviceable, but I really wish I could have walked out of there with the new ones! He didn't say on pricing, but suspect it should be in the $125-150 range judging by the website pricing.

 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next
EddyTurn
distinguished member (268)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/14/2024 07:30PM  
If you expect to walk on wet rocky terrain I'd advise against the Merge, at least in it's previous reincarnation, I had many more falls in one season wearing the Merge than any other wet-footing shoes. I found Rassler 2.0 to be far better in that respect.
 
03/15/2024 07:46AM  
Astral has two types of sole rubber; the Rasslers have the stickier stuff. Merge, Loyak and Brewers have the more durable stuff.
 
03/15/2024 08:08AM  
It's all relative, I suppose. I haven't worn them much yet as I just got them last fall, but so far I've been happy with the wet grip on my TR1 Meshes compared to the Keens and Merrells I've had. I wonder if the extra durability really matters on a shoe that's so lightly built to begin with. I suspect that the uppers will be trashed long before the soles. We'll see I guess.
 
portagedog09
distinguished member (174)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/15/2024 04:33PM  
EddyTurn: "If you expect to walk on wet rocky terrain I'd advise against the Merge, at least in it's previous reincarnation, I had many more falls in one season wearing the Merge than any other wet-footing shoes. I found Rassler 2.0 to be far better in that respect."


I have the Rassler as well and have portaged Quetico in it, before they made the TR1. It has a very thin footbed - like 9mm I think, and it's very soft. Step on a sharp rock and you'll feel it. It has no shank to support your arch. Yes, it has the GSS compound sole and with the siping, they offer Spiderman like grip on smooth, slick surfaces. It's lower top also offers little protection for ankles from the sharp granite up there. Get into some clay or muddy situations and you might as well be wearing a pair of dress shoes. They are great for rivers, not so much for portages.

The TR1 has a thicker footbed, like 15-16mm and a thermoplastic shank with an agressive tread more suited to carrying heavy loads over rough, muddy, mucky terrain. The 2.0 version is also supposed to have a softer compound tread. Even in the 1.0 configuration, I found it a better match for the BW/Q portage trails. YMMV

pd
 
03/15/2024 06:58PM  
plmn: "It's all relative, I suppose. I haven't worn them much yet as I just got them last fall, but so far I've been happy with the wet grip on my TR1 Meshes compared to the Keens and Merrells I've had. I wonder if the extra durability really matters on a shoe that's so lightly built to begin with. I suspect that the uppers will be trashed long before the soles. We'll see I guess. "


My TR1 Meshes have been great for traction as well, but you're right, the uppers aren't very durable. It makes sense since they're mostly mesh. I found that the mesh started to tear away from the bottom and started allowing debris into the shoe so I had to shake little rocks and sand out a lot. They did replace the shoes once as a courtesy but told me that, technically, it's expected wear and tear. I like how lightweight they are and they do have great grip, so I'm still rocking the worn pair until they get too beat up, and then I'll use the new pair. I like them as camp shoes as well when I'm using my NRS Boundary Boot as my wetfoot shoe.
 
03/15/2024 08:05PM  
JD: "My TR1 Meshes have been great for traction as well, but you're right, the uppers aren't very durable. It makes sense since they're mostly mesh. I found that the mesh started to tear away from the bottom and started allowing debris into the shoe so I had to shake little rocks and sand out a lot. They did replace the shoes once as a courtesy but told me that, technically, it's expected wear and tear. I like how lightweight they are and they do have great grip, so I'm still rocking the worn pair until they get too beat up, and then I'll use the new pair. I like them as camp shoes as well when I'm using my NRS Boundary Boot as my wetfoot shoe."


I wanted something breathable and light and quick drying so I knew going in I was giving up durability. It's more running shoe than hiker. If they last a couple of years I'll be satisfied with them.

 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next
Gear Sponsor:
Fishell Paddles