|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Listening Point - General Discussion Paddle question |
Author
Text
06/04/2018 03:58PM
Hi All
Last year when going up to the BWCA in July I forgot my second paddle. So when I went to the Outfitters to pick up our permit they had some used older paddles for a few dollars. I bought a bent shaft paddle but it’s very heavy. Has anyone ever tried to make a wooden paddle lighter?
Please advise if you have ideas.
Thanks
Mike
Last year when going up to the BWCA in July I forgot my second paddle. So when I went to the Outfitters to pick up our permit they had some used older paddles for a few dollars. I bought a bent shaft paddle but it’s very heavy. Has anyone ever tried to make a wooden paddle lighter?
Please advise if you have ideas.
Thanks
Mike
"Love many, trust a few, and always paddle your own canoe"
06/04/2018 07:08PM
I’m thinking none of you have done it. Yes it’s easy to just go out and buy something. That someone else made. Then what you have bragging points that you have something better? But to me the most gratifying things that bring me the most happiness is the most annoying and difficult things I do in life. Think gardening or raising kids. Rebuilding a sailboat or canoe or paddle. Buying something off the shelf loses its happiness value nearly immediately. Just my opinion of course. Good luck with your new things. Ill screw around with this old paddle. It might break but might not and I’ll have something to be proud of in the future if it holds up. I’d much rather have something that my grandpa tinkered around with and made it his own then the lightest most expensive paddle out there. But there you go. That’s me anyways.
"Love many, trust a few, and always paddle your own canoe"
06/04/2018 08:13PM
I think your biggest problem is the type of wood. Some wood is just heavier, but then possibly stronger. If that’s the case maybe you can thin the blade down and make the shaft smaller. Like you said the worst thing that could happen is it breaks, on the other hand it might work. Sounds like you have enough paddles so won’t use it as is so you really have nothing to lose. Good luck
06/04/2018 08:13PM
I think your biggest problem is the type of wood. Some wood is just heavier, but then possibly stronger. If that’s the case maybe you can thin the blade down and make the shaft smaller. Like you said the worst thing that could happen is it breaks, on the other hand it might work. Sounds like you have enough paddles so won’t use it as is so you really have nothing to lose. Good luck
06/04/2018 08:16PM
Whatsit: "I’m thinking none of you have done it. Yes it’s easy to just go out and buy something. That someone else made. Then what you have bragging points that you have something better? But to me the most gratifying things that bring me the most happiness is the most annoying and difficult things I do in life. Think gardening or raising kids. Rebuilding a sailboat or canoe or paddle. Buying something off the shelf loses its happiness value nearly immediately. Just my opinion of course. Good luck with your new things. Ill screw around with this old paddle. It might break but might not and I’ll have something to be proud of in the future if it holds up. I’d much rather have something that my grandpa tinkered around with and made it his own then the lightest most expensive paddle out there. But there you go. That’s me anyways. "
+1
06/05/2018 07:32AM
Doubt it’s possible. It’s most likely heavy because of the wood species that it was made with. Most light paddles are cedar and basswood with maybe one or two strips of a hardwood like walnut- but mostly light woods. There’s nothing you can do to fix that.
Another suggestion- if you really want to do something cool then why not just make your own from scratch? It’s not that hard and I think would be easier than trying to somehow make the other lighter- then you’ll have a REAL heirloom.
Another suggestion- if you really want to do something cool then why not just make your own from scratch? It’s not that hard and I think would be easier than trying to somehow make the other lighter- then you’ll have a REAL heirloom.
06/05/2018 04:35PM
I've seen a few paddles that were not just heavy wood but also carved more like a club than a paddle. If it is one of those, then I would read up on paddle making and then treat it as a blank that needs more work and shave it down. You just need to figure out where it can be thinner (probably the blade but maybe not the shaft).
On the other hand, if it is a lot of work maybe it is better used as the basis for a wall decoration and then spend the woodworking effort on better wood. Or practice some woodworking on it and then turn it into a decoration.
On the other hand, if it is a lot of work maybe it is better used as the basis for a wall decoration and then spend the woodworking effort on better wood. Or practice some woodworking on it and then turn it into a decoration.
06/05/2018 08:36PM
andym: "...treat it as a blank that needs more work and shave it down...
...practice some woodworking on it..."
This.
If it works, great! If not, you've built some skills and experience, and maybe a genuine interest in making your own from scratch.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here